Why Corked Wine Is Personal

Identifying the taste and aroma of TCA is different for everyone

Portrait of Wine Spectator senior editor Kristen Bieler
Senior editor Kristen Bieler says that wine lovers must develop their own benchmarks for detecting TCA and other wine flaws, instead of focusing on a “wet cardboard” character. (Lucy Schaeffer)

When many of us start learning to taste wine, it's commonly taught that a “corked” bottle is easily recognizable by a “wet cardboard” aroma. But not everyone can pick that up. There are a number of ways a wine can be flawed (heat damage, oxidation, bacterial problems) but corkiness is caused by trichloroanisole, or TCA, a compound that can live in the bark of cork trees (or form at other stages of cork and wine production). Perceptions of cork taint vary by degree—sometimes impossible to miss, other times so subtle that only someone very familiar with the wine can detect it. But it also varies widely by taster perception.

Senior editor Kristen Bieler explains how she developed her own internal aroma and taste markers for detecting TCA contamination, also known as “cork taint” or “corkiness” in wine. Learn how you can too!

Member-Only Content

Premium Subscription

Join today and get immediate access to this article, and to our entire database of more than 450,000 wine ratings. It only takes moments—but it will help you drink better all year long.

Start Free 30-day Trial

Already a member? Sign In

Try Winespectator.com Free for 30 Days!

Full access to our database of more than 425,000 wine ratings

Early access to reviews on our editors' favorite just-rated wines

Wine and food pairing tool,
chefs' pairing recommendations

Best value wines and winery intel

Subscribe today

You Might Also Like

Wine Lovers Win on Science, Lose on Noise

Wine Lovers Win on Science, Lose on Noise

When research shows balanced, moderate wine consumption can be healthy, anti-alcohol …

Oct 8, 2025
The Biggest Mistake with 2022 Cabernet

The Biggest Mistake with 2022 Cabernet

It should have been a no-brainer for Napa wineries to drop prices on a lesser vintage

Nov 15, 2025
The Last Grape

The Last Grape

The Rhône’s often overlooked Muscardin grape is gaining attention in California

Oct 15, 2025
Wines from 130-Year-Old Vines

Wines from 130-Year-Old Vines

Tasting a vertical of Williams Selyem Zinfandels from centennial vines

Oct 31, 2025
Soul Food

Soul Food

Enjoying Santiago chef Rodolfo Guzman’s evocative Chilean cuisine

Oct 31, 2025
Remembering The Father of Wine Country Cuisine

Remembering The Father of Wine Country Cuisine

In Sonoma and Mendocino kitchens and through his writing, chef John Ash helped teach …

Aug 20, 2025